Ghosting, Fraud, & Automation Woes: What Brokers Told Us In 2025

Freight brokers shared a lot in 2025. We distilled a year’s worth of insights into eight charts so you can carry the most actionable data into 2026.

Ghosting, Fraud, & Automation Woes: What Brokers Told Us In 2025

If 2024 was the year brokers experimented with new tools, 2025 was the year they got honest about what’s actually holding them back.

Across thousands of votes, FreightCaviar’s LinkedIn polls revealed the same themes again and again: broken communication, messy back-office operations, stalled automation, fraud headaches, and frustrated carrier relationships.

All of it points to one thing: brokers lack time, visibility, and operational clarity.

So for this final Epay Manager blog of the year, we’re breaking down the top poll insights from 2025, and what they mean for teams heading into 2026 – plus the practical fixes to turn these bottlenecks into advantages. 

Brokers Want to Grow, But Not by Hiring More People

  • Poll: What’s most impactful for growth in 2025? 
    • 38% choosing new tech + 38% choosing automation shows brokers are done relying on headcount expansion as their scaling strategy.
    • Only 18% said hiring more people.

What this tells us: Growth now comes from doing more with the team you have rather than endless hiring. 

What to do in 2026:

  • Growth now depends on operational leverage, not headcount.
  • Tech that streamlines manual tasks like invoicing and audits becomes a competitive advantage.
  • Brokerages that automate early will win.

Where Epay fits: Epay’s automated invoicing and auditing workflows let brokers increase volume without increasing payroll, exactly what this poll reflects.

Communication Issues Are the #1 Carrier Relationship Problem

  • 69% of brokers said communication issues are their biggest challenge with carriers. 
  • And when asked what type? 65% said slow replies or ghosting.  

This means that there isn’t a people problem; there is a process problem. Carriers aren’t ignoring brokers. They’re overwhelmed by scattered emails, missing documents, unclear payment statuses, and too many apps. 

What to do in 2026:

  • Centralize communication around invoices, PODs, and payments.
  • Give carriers self-serve visibility into what’s approved, pending, or missing.
  • Reduce the confusion → reduce the ghosting.

Where Epay helps: Epay’s Portal offers unique logins to both carriers and factors to allow for real-time transparency to invoicing and payment status to eliminate the “What’s the status?” back-and-forth entirely.

Automation Stalls Because Tools Don’t Integrate (Not Because Brokers Don’t Want It)

When we asked brokers why they’re hesitant to adopt automation, 45% said integration complexity, more than cost, lack of time, or operational inertia. 

Basically, that translates into “Please don’t give me another tool that doesn’t talk to my TMS.” 

What to do in 2026:

  • Choose tools with real, working integrations (not just “coming soon”).
  • Go for phased rollouts: automate one workflow, measure results, then expand.
  • Make vendors prove they can reduce work, not create new tabs.

Where Epay helps: Epay integrates directly with major TMS platforms and has guided onboarding so teams can adopt automation without chaos.

Fraud Fears Exploded, And Double Brokering Still Reigns

In June, we saw the highest-engagement poll of the year:

71% of brokers said double brokering is their #1 fraud concern, followed by fake documents at 14% – the sleeper issue that quietly drives disputed, delayed payments, and internal audit headaches. 

A key note is that double brokering relies on fake documents. Without believable documents, double brokering quickly collapses. 

What to do in 2026:

  • Automated document checks catch mismatches instantly
  • Signature, amount, and data validation surfaces inconsistencies
  • Controlled bank-change workflows prevent hijacked payments
  • Pre-billing verification stops fake or incomplete docs before accounting ever sees them

Epay’s AI audit engine is built specifically to catch mismatched or suspicious documents before they hit accounting.

Emotional Intelligence as the Most Underrated Skill in Brokerage

In August, 36% of brokers voted emotional intelligence as the industry’s most underrated skill, beating multitasking and even adaptability.

Why? Because when the market is tough, relationships outperform hustle. 

What to do in 2026:

  • Build trust through transparency and consistency.
  • Make payment processes clean, predictable, and dispute-free.
  • Communicate proactively, not reactively.

Where Epay helps: When your back office is organized, clear, and fast, your carrier relationships improve organically without you having to “work on” soft skills. 

POD Collection Is Still a Mess and It’s Slowing Down Cash Flow

In the August poll, 68% of freight brokers listed delays in POD submission as their top frustration. Another 22% cited unreadable images.

Why this problem persists:

POD issues trigger a chain reaction:

Late POD → late invoice → late carrier pay → late cash flow

The 2026 fix

  • Automate POD reminders
  • Validate image quality before accounting sees it
  • Standardize submission through a single channel

Where Epay fits: Epay prevents incomplete or unusable PODs from ever entering billing, which reduces disputes and accelerates payment cycles. 

Customer Service Is the True Differentiator in a Crowded Market

In September, 51% of brokers chose customer service as the distinguishing factor for successful brokerages. Only 8% chose technology adoption.

In practice, customer service means:

  • Clean, accurate paperwork
  • Fast dispute resolution
  • Predictable payment timelines
  • Clear communication
  • Dependable processes shippers can trust

Epay strengthens service by eliminating back-office chaos, making every invoice, every payment, and every document reliable.

The 2026 Broker Playbook: What These Polls Make Clear 

Across every poll, brokers repeatedly highlighted five business realities: 

  1. Growth comes from automation
  2. Carrier communication needs structure
  3. Integrations decide whether tech actually gets used
  4. Fraud prevention starts with document integrity
  5. Customer service is the ultimate differentiator

Epay Manager is already solving these exact pain points with automated audits, transparent workflows, seamless integration, and friction-free carrier communication. 

If 2025 revealed the patterns, 2026 is the year brokers finally fix them. 


Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to FreightCaviar.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.