💸 Brokers That Went Broke In 2023

Happy Hump Day. We're taking a close look at 2023's freight brokerage failures and the key lessons they offer for the industry. We also feature stories on C.H. Robinson's effective headcount cuts, insights from trucking executives on the freight cycle's future, and the intriguing saga of the stolen Kit Kats. Don’t miss our quick hits on Elite Transit's whistleblowers and the new '1st Ladies of Freight' reality show.

In today's email:

• Three Freight Headlines: C.H. Robinson's boosts productivity amid major headcount cuts, trucking execs predict a market upswing, and the curious case of stolen Kit Kats.
• Learning from Freight Brokerage Failures in 2023
• Around the Freight Web: Whistleblowers allege unpaid wages at Elite Transit, a $4M Panama Canal shortcut, and a legal battle over a freight merger.
• Carrier of the Week

TOP LANE MOVERS POWERED BY GREENSCREENS.AI

*Greenscreens.ai, forecasts real-time truckload buy prices that are suited to each freight brokerage's purchasing power using AI and machine learning. Its engine takes into account over 130 attributes and data points in each rate forecast.

🐔 WHAT’S COOKIN’ IN FREIGHT

🗡️ C.H. Robinson Slashes Headcount, Cuts Expenses. C.H. Robinson reduced its headcount by 14.2% YoY in Q3, leading to a 21.5% drop in personnel expenses. To achieve these reductions, the company implemented layoffs, attrition, retirements, and role eliminations. The firm also automated processes and embraced AI as part of its cost-cutting strategy amid challenging freight conditions. Operating expenses decreased by 13.1% YoY, while productivity gains were achieved, improving efficiency in its North American Surface Transportation and Global Forwarding segments.

👨‍💼 Trucking Executives Foresee Market Rebound. Top trucking executives from Ryder, Schneider National, and Werner Enterprises anticipate a market rebound in the near future. Ryder's CEO predicts the freight cycle bottoming by early 2024, highlighting strengths in specific sectors. Schneider views 2024 as a year of transition with gradual improvements in market fundamentals. Werner's CEO points to a market nearing balance, evidenced by significant carrier deactivations and company bankruptcies. Despite current challenges, there's a sense of cautious optimism for a gradual recovery in the trucking industry.

🍫 Stolen Kit Kats Saga. In a bizarre tale of strategic theft, 55,000 rare Kit Kats were stolen in an elaborate cargo heist. The sought-after Japanese treats, intended for a New York company, vanished during transit, involving fake truckers, shell email accounts, and supply-chain fraud. Freight broker Shane Black was unwittingly caught in the scheme. The stolen sweets were discovered in California, but a complex web of deception left half of them lost forever, a value of $110,000 gone. This incident sheds light on the $30 billion annual problem of strategic theft, which we wrote about on Monday, and highlights the challenges in tracking down stolen goods in the modern supply chain.

GET INTEGRATED WITH OTR SOLUTIONS BROKER SERVICES

Scale Your Brokerage with OTR Solutions. Stop spending hours on carrier pay. With OTR Solutions Broker Services and Open API, you can pay all your carriers in a single transaction. Need help with cash float issues? OTR can help with that, too. You can even start offering quick pay and generate revenue from OTR, helping you stay competitive in the market. OTR Solutions is focused on helping the everyday freight broker choose the services you need and OTR will handle the rest. 

Get started today by visiting their website and see the difference they can make for your brokerage. 

Learning from Freight Brokerage Failures in 2023

The freight industry has witnessed a notable number of brokerage bankruptcies in 2023, shedding light on the vulnerabilities and challenges within the sector.

Meadow Lark Agency and Meadow Lark Transport:

• Bankruptcy Date: November 2023
• Reasons for Failure: A combination of banking and funding issues, higher costs with lower rates, and insurance challenges exacerbated by a cyberattack.
• Impact: Nearly 120 ex-employees and around 1,300 trucking companies were affected financially.
• Takeaway: Robust cybersecurity measures and financial resilience are crucial for mitigating unforeseen challenges.

Surge Transportation:

• Bankruptcy Date: July 2023
• Reasons for Failure: The post-COVID e-commerce boom was followed by an unanticipated and rapid drop in product demand and increased shipping costs.
• Impact: Owed approximately $12 million to 5,000 trucking companies.
• Takeaway: Managing revenue volatility through flexible operating expenses is vital for weathering market fluctuations.

Convoy:

• Closure Date: October 2023
• Reasons for Failure: An "unprecedented freight market collapse" and "dramatic monetary tightening" led to unsustainable operations despite previous substantial backing.
• Impact: Closure affected 500 employees.
• Takeaway: Diversification of funding sources and realistic growth projections can help navigate financial climates. Market volatility demands flexibility in business models and readiness for rapid adjustments.

SEL Supply Chain Solutions:

• Closure Date: October 2023
• Reason for Failure: A series of incidents starting with a major theft, followed by increased costs and banking restrictions, leading to limited access to capital.
• Impact: Affecting 125 people, including 45 independent agents.
• Takeaway: Robust risk management and solid banking relationships are critical

But There's More:

Data aggregated from the FMCSA by TruckInfo.net revealed that more than 1,500 freight brokers have closed in 2023.

Plus, Major Layoffs in Freight Brokerages:

The industry also saw significant layoffs as companies struggled.

• C.H. Robinson: up to 1,200 employees, ultimately laid off approximately 650 employees.
• Flexport: plans to lay off 20% of its workforce.
• Elite Transit Solutions: approximately 85 employees.
• Coyote Logistics: an overall 7% decrease in staff over the past two years.
• Uber Freight: cut 150 jobs in January and nearly 50 freight brokerage employees in July.

The freight brokerage industry's 2023 turmoil underscores the importance of agile business models, strategic financial management, and robust risk mitigation. These challenges are a call to reevaluate and innovate, prioritizing adaptability and foresight. Getting through the current difficulties is crucial, but the ability to prepare for future uncertainty will define the sector's long-term health.

Sources: FreightWaves | TruckInfo.net

THE WORLD'S MOST POPULAR TMS

AscendTMS is the world's most popular & best-rated TMS. Use our referral code RA-FreightCaviar! to receive 3 months of AscendTMS Premium for free. It only takes 20 seconds to sign up and no credit card is required. Click here to learn more.

AROUND THE FREIGHT WEB

🚨 Elite Transit Whistleblowers Claim Unpaid Wages. Last week, we wrote about the layoff of 65 employees at Elite Transit Solutions and received numerous emails regarding deeper issues at the company. Allegations suggest brokers are not receiving their due payments, raising concerns about self-dealing practices. The situation is evolving, casting a shadow on the company's reputation.

🚢 LNG Carrier Pays $4 Million to Skip Panama Canal Line. An LNG carrier shelled out $4 million to skip the Panama Canal line, a drastic measure due to cargo boiling off under the tropical sun. The standard transit fee for such vessels is $400,000.

👩‍⚖️ Merger Legal Battle. In a complex legal twist, Forward Air files a counterclaim against Omni Specialized, seeking an exit from their merger agreement.

🛑 Alert: Industry Scam. Freight brokers should be on high alert for a new scam circulating in the industry, with the actual carrier and scammer joining forces.

♀️ Women in Trucking Reality Show. The '1st Ladies of Freight' showcase the vital role of women in the trucking industry. Available at the link above and on ROKU TV.

💡 Recession’s Ripple Effect. An expert breaks down how the 'Great Trucking Recession' could broadly impact American economy and logistics.

🚚 Rethinking the Shortage. Is the driver shortage as critical as perceived? New insights challenge the prevailing narrative in the trucking industry.

FREIGHT CONFERENCES WE'RE ATTENDING

Manifest Vegas, February 5 - 7, 2024, is the world's largest global supply chain & logistics tech event, bringing together Fortune 500 global supply chain executives, logistics service providers, cutting-edge startups, venture investors, and technology leaders.  Join 4,500+ supply chain innovators to foster new strategies and relationships. Receive $200 off your ticket with our exclusive link.

CARRIER OF THE WEEK PRESENTED BY LOSTFR8.COM

Founded in 2015 by Cristina Fetila and David Miron, CDS Transport Inc., based in Chicago, IL, specializes in operating 53’ reefers, mainly between AZ/CA and the Midwest. Their frequent reefer capacity locations include Chicago, IL, Lincoln, NE, and Bakersfield, CA. Reed Loustalot, a long-time collaborator since 2017, highly commends David for his exceptional reliability, recalling a time when despite a dangerous accident, David ensured timely delivery. Cristina and David's excellence in service has made CDS Transport a trusted partner, notably as LOST FR8’s second customer. Click here to view their Lost Fr8 Profile.

FREIGHT MEME OF THE DAY